Notes from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDJVg3K-KC0
Verses used to support their application
Confession or eye-witnesses
Deut 19:15
Mat 18:16
1Ti 5:19
Problematic other verses. Certain crimes happen in secret and won't have witnesses.
Deut 22:25-27
WT Dec 2019 QFR
Even in cases with only 1 witness people can use their judgment.
How investigation reveals truth.
What does WT do when a child makes an accusation.
No investigation was made.
This passage is designed to protect elders from malicious, false or petty accusations. Read verse 20 as well.
Selective Application.
WT applies the 2 witness rule selectively. They can rule without seeing the actual sin when, only circumstantial evidence.
Mat 18:6; 23:23
Psa 82:3-4; James 1:27 Ezek 34:4-5